In the chaotic, meta-textual spectacle of Gremlins 2: The New Batch, Joe Dante unleashes a menagerie of mutated monsters, each embodying a different facet of consumerism and corporate excess. Among them, however, one figure stands out for its unsettling departure from the typical Gremlin savagery: the Brain Gremlin. This bespectacled, articulate creature, imbued with an unexpected intellect after consuming a potent brain-enhancing serum, offers fertile ground for a Lacanian psychoanalytic interpretation. Far from a mere comical villain, the Brain Gremlin embodies key Lacanian concepts such as the Mirror Stage, the Symbolic Order, the Imaginary, and the Real, presenting a grotesque, yet compelling, exploration of identity formation and the inherent instability of the ego.
The Brain Gremlin’s Genesis: A Perverse Mirror Stage
Lacan’s Mirror Stage describes a crucial moment in the development of the human infant, where it first recognizes its own image in a mirror or in the gaze of another. This recognition, however, is a misrecognition (méconnaissance), a premature grasp of a unified self that is, in reality, still fragmented and motorically uncoordinated. The infant identifies with this complete image, forming the ego – an illusory sense of mastery and coherence. The Brain Gremlin’s genesis can be seen as a perverse, accelerated Mirror Stage.
Unlike its brethren, who are born from the chaotic, undifferentiated mass of Gizmo’s wet fur, the Brain Gremlin’s transformation is mediated by a scientific concoction. The brain serum acts as a literal, albeit chemical, “mirror.” It doesn’t merely enhance cognitive function; it bestows upon the Gremlin a recognition of intellectual potential, a capacity for structured thought that was previously absent. Before this, all Gremlins exist in a state of primal, undifferentiated aggression – a pre-Mirror Stage existence dominated by the Real of their insatiable hunger and destructive drives. The serum, however, offers an idealized image of intellectual power, a potential for control and order that immediately forms the basis of the Brain Gremlin’s emergent, albeit monstrous, ego. This is a false coherence, however, built on a foundation that is fundamentally alien to its Gremlin nature. It’s a misrecognition in its purest form: a Gremlin believing it can transcend its chaotic essence through intellect.
Entry into the Symbolic Order: Language and Law
Following the Mirror Stage, the individual enters the Symbolic Order, the realm of language, law, and social structures. This is the realm of the Big Other, the collective unconscious, which shapes our identities and desires. For the Brain Gremlin, its consumption of the serum immediately propels it into a forced, yet surprisingly adept, entry into the Symbolic. It gains the power of language, articulated through a refined, almost Shakespearean vocabulary. This is not merely communication; it’s the adoption of the very tools of human civilization, the means by which subjects are constituted within a social framework.
The Brain Gremlin’s first articulate words are not random growls but reasoned arguments and plans for domination. It immediately attempts to impose order on the chaotic Gremlin horde, seeking to establish a hierarchy and a strategic approach to taking over the Clamp building. This attempt to introduce law and structure among its brethren, to move them beyond their immediate, chaotic drives, directly reflects the function of the Symbolic Order. It’s a grotesque parody of civilizing influence, a monster attempting to impose human logic on fundamentally illogical beings. The other Gremlins, however, largely resist this imposition, remaining stubbornly rooted in their pre-Symbolic, destructive impulses. This highlights the inherent friction when a subject attempts to fully assimilate into a Symbolic Order that is not organically theirs.
The Return of the Real: The Unruly Drive
Despite the Brain Gremlin’s sophisticated foray into the Symbolic and its self-aggrandizing Imaginary constructions, the Real of its Gremlin essence consistently erupts, threatening to shatter its fragile intellectual facade. The Real, for Lacan, is that which resists symbolization, that which remains outside of language and imagination. It is the unrepresentable, the traumatic kernel of existence, often manifesting as primal drives and anxieties.
For the Brain Gremlin, the Real is the inherent, destructive Gremlin drive that it strives to suppress or control. While it attempts to reason, to plan, and to lead with intellectual prowess, its core biological imperative remains. This is most evident in the constant threat of its own kind undermining its plans through sheer, unadulterated chaos. The other Gremlins’ inability or unwillingness to follow its intellectual directives, their preference for immediate gratification (eating, destroying, causing mayhem), and their vulnerability to basic Gremlin weaknesses (sunlight, water) constantly frustrate the Brain Gremlin’s rational schemes.
Furthermore, the very source of its intellect – the serum – is an artificial imposition. The Gremlin’s body is still fundamentally that of a monster, governed by primal urges. The intellectual veneer is thin; a moment of stress or frustration could theoretically cause its fragile ego to crack, revealing the underlying Gremlin savagery. The film never fully explores this internal conflict, but the tension between its intellectual aspirations and its inherent monstrous nature is palpable. Its intellect is an attempt to master the Real, to bring it under Symbolic control, but the Real is ultimately unmasterable. Its sophisticated arguments are always on the verge of collapsing into primal screams, a constant reminder of the beast within.
The Fall: The Deconstruction of the Ego
The Brain Gremlin’s ultimate downfall is a quintessential Lacanian deconstruction of the ego. Its carefully constructed Imaginary identity and its attempts to master the Symbolic Order are ultimately undone by the very forces it sought to control. Its elaborate plans fail, not due to a lack of intelligence, but because they are predicated on the assumption that it can entirely transcend its fundamental Gremlin nature and that of its kind.
The culmination of its intellectual hubris is its final, operatic confrontation with Clamp, where it attempts to intellectualize its dominance through song. This grand, performative gesture is the ultimate expression of its Imaginary identification with human culture and its desire for symbolic recognition. However, it’s immediately undercut by the arrival of sunlight, the ultimate, unavoidable Real for all Gremlins. Its intellect, its plans, its tailored suit, and its refined speech are utterly powerless against the biological imperative of its species. The sudden, ignominious melting of the Brain Gremlin is not just physical destruction; it’s the spectacular dissolution of an ego that was built on a fundamental misrecognition, a testament to the fact that the Imaginary and Symbolic can only ever provide a partial, fragile mastery over the unyielding Real.
Conclusion: A Monstrous Mirror for Humanity
The Brain Gremlin, in its brief but memorable appearance in Gremlins 2, offers more than just comedic relief or a bizarre villain. Through a Lacanian lens, it becomes a fascinating, albeit grotesque, psychoanalytic case study. It mirrors, in a distorted fashion, the human journey through the Mirror Stage into the Symbolic Order, highlighting the fragility of the ego and the persistent, unmasterable presence of the Real. The Brain Gremlin’s intellectual aspirations, its attempts to impose order and logic, and its ultimate failure against its own chaotic nature serve as a satirical, yet profound, commentary on the human condition itself. We, too, construct our identities and societies through symbolic structures and imaginary ideals, constantly striving to tame the unpredictable Real within and around us. The Brain Gremlin’s hubris and its subsequent melt-down are a vivid, if darkly comic, reminder of the inherent limitations of this endeavor, suggesting that even the most advanced intellect cannot entirely escape the primal, undifferentiated drives that lurk beneath the surface. It is, in essence, a monstrous mirror reflecting our own precarious grasp on identity and control.
Bibliography
[1] Lacan, J. (2006). Écrits: The First Complete Edition in English. (B. Fink, Trans.). W. W. Norton & Company. (Specifically, “The Mirror Stage as Formative of the I Function as Revealed in Psychoanalytic Experience” is highly relevant.)
[2] Evans, D. (1996). An Introductory Dictionary of Lacanian Psychoanalysis. Routledge. (Provides excellent definitions and explanations of key Lacanian terms.)
[3] Fink, B. (1995). The Lacanian Subject: From Language to Jouissance. Princeton University Press. (Offers deeper insights into the Symbolic, Imaginary, and Real.)
[4] Gremlins 2: The New Batch. (1990). Directed by Joe Dante. Warner Bros. Pictures. (The primary text for analysis.)
[5] Zizek, S. (2008). The Sublime Object of Ideology. Verso. (While not directly about Gremlins, Žižek’s applications of Lacan to popular culture offer a framework for such analysis.)
[6] McGowan, T. (2004). The End of the Party: David Lynch, Lacan, and the Anxiety of Masculinity. Stanford University Press. (Provides examples of applying Lacanian theory to film.)
Opinions of one T. Watt 